Heads up: There is a significant effort Gavin Menzies Royal Navy Submarine Commanding Officer, retired was born in in China, where he spent the first two years of his life. He joined the Royal Navy in and served in submarines from to Since leaving the Royal Navy, he has returned to China and the Far East many times, and in the course of researching he has visited countries, over museums and libraries and every major sea port of the late Middle Ages.
Gavin Menzies is married with two daughters and lives in North London.
- More Comments:.
- Discover Your Divine LIFE Design: 7 Secrets To Joy & Wealth;
- Griffith REVIEW 41: Now We Are Ten.
- Gavin Menzies: mad as a snake - or a visionary??
- The Orbit of Mercury: Two Stories;
- Slave Mansion 3 (Erotic Stories of Sexual Domination and Submission).
- Is Gavin Menzies Right or Wrong?;
Gavin Menzies. On 8 February the largest fleet the world had ever seen sailed from its base in China. The ships, foot long junks made from the finest teak and mahogany, were led by Emperor Zhu Di's loyal eunuch admirals.
- The Collected Works of Hugh Nibley, Vol. 4: Mormonism and Early Christianity!
- 1421 : The Year China Discovered the World -- Paperback / softback [Paperback].
- Ukulele Me 2013 (Instant Knowledge)!
- Breathless X (Blue Fire Saga Book 1).
- : the year China discovered the world / Gavin Menzies | National Library of Australia.
- See a Problem?.
- Find a copy in the library!
Their mission was 'to proceed all the way to the end of the earth to collect tribute from the barbarians beyond the seas' and unite the whole world in Confucian harmony. Their journey would last over two years and circle the entire globe. When they returned Zhu Di had fallen from power and China was beginning its long, self-imposed isolation from the world it had so recently embraced. Wikipedia has an article dedicated to the hypothesis , which lists some detailed criticism, specially about the Chinese discovering Austrialia.
An article by Geoff Wade describing as a fairytale and fiction. Salon has an article describing the book as an "object lesson in amateurish research, slapdash editing and publishing greed". A book review by John Wills mentions the PBS program, and how Menzies is cross-examined on camera, politely but firmly, and several times has to admit that he may be mistaken on a particular point. Bill Hartz says in Gavin's fantasy land : "it is not really a history, it's a poser, and belongs on the fiction list".
A Spanish site called A Chinoise story lists some details from Spanish archives and sources. The Language blog has an article about the linguistic portion of the evidence. There is also an update on that article. The Australian has a Junk history article.
The Year China Discovered America - Gavin Menzies - Google книги
On AllEmpires. Gavin Menzies has some very creative interpretations and some pretty convincing evidence, especially finding Chinese genomes in people at various points along the routes he proposes for the Chinese fleet. His knowledge of currents and winds is far beyond that of a typical history scholar.
But even an average reader like me found several glaring errors in the book " First, he referred to huge waves encountered at sea and proposed they might have been tsunamis. Tsunamis are barely detectable on the open sea, though they travel at incredible speeds. The long wave type "feels bottom" in shallow water and rises in response. Like surf does. Second, he wrote of Maya people on the west coast of Mexico. They live now, and lived then, on the Yucatan peninsula and into the highlands of Central America.
How Not to (Re)Write World History: Gavin Menzies and the Chinese Discovery of America
Nauatl speaking groups lived on the west coast, and still do. Finding only these two rather glaring errors caused me to be suspicious part way through "" of the quality of his other findings, and to expect some of his facts and research may not have been of the highest integrity. And yet, I think he may be onto something. Recall that in the 50s real scholars scoffed at the crazy idea of plate tectonics. New ideas challenge old thinking, shake up staid and serious people. Extraordinary claims demand extraordinary evidence.
I want to see more DNA comparisons before I decide. Might he have more 1st hand knowledge of tsunamis than you find in Eugene? Except for a few specific points, I don't even think that Menzies would disagree with you much.
He knows that many of his points are insufficient to be accepted by science. His prose and the speculative nature of his historic recounting composes the special appeal of his books. He makes compelling if not always perfect arguments. As ling his does not set historical research backward very far and possibly even leads to a regime of new historical truths being discovered, I am all for it. In fact, his work has pointed me to some actual evidence of certain aspects of history of which I was previously unaware, not that it was unknown to historians following academic tradition.
Contribute to This Page
I recently read Menzie's latest book on this subject and I have to say the ongoing DNA evidence is proving him more right than wrong. I have no idea if this comment section is still running or if anyone is reading it What is of even more interest to me is the Minoan culture and the copper mines in Michigan. Also the remains of a culture on the Florida coast being dated well before the first clovis point. It's a real long term problem among established establishment true believers OnStep is a full featured telescope controller. You can order kits for building your own, as well as a Smart Hand Controller.
Sofa Bed NZ. Skip to main content. You are here Pseudoscience: Lots of it around